Camera
- Panning shot of maids - conforms to eastern European stereotype of working in the public sector - European people, Ethnicity
- Diegetic dialogue - booze girls ganja - depicts dangerous reckless behaviour shown during shot reverse shot - Black people, Race
Sound
- Diegetic dialogue - difference in way of speaking. colloquial language "blood" and "ganja" as opposed to well spoken staff - Black people, Race
- Diegetic sound bridge of dialogue - "British plague" counter stereotype/irony said from an Italian now in Britain - British people, Ethnicity
Mise en scene
- Difference in mannerisms when talking to guests and talking to friend, more thug-like stances and movements as opposed to rigid stand up straight posture of guests - Black people, Race
- Tattoos and braids on friend and no tattoos with business hair cut on staff - Black people, Race
Editing
- Scene transition using pillars to transition between scenes. each frame shows a white guest - upper class money - White people, Race
- Jump cutting of full 2 shot, close ups and medium 2 shots showing people with head caps typical within Islamic faith - Islamic people, Ethnicity
Essay
Within the extract of hotel Babylon, race and ethnicity are presented as both stereotypical and counter stereotypical through the use of camera, mise en scene, editing and sound. Race is defined as dividing people into groups based on physical characteristics, whilst ethnicity is a group of people with common traditions and/or faiths.
Firstly, camera, sound and mise en scene are used to represent ethnicity when there is a panning shot on the maids. They are shown wheeling carts and wearing maids outfits; the standard black dress with the white apron and a white hair tie. When they spoke, they spoke with a Franco-British accent, evident that they had been living in the country for some time after having migrated here. This conforms to the typical stereotype of eastern European people coming into the country and taking all of the blue collar public sector jobs that are in the UK. This has recently been made a common stereotype through people from countries all over Europe, such as Bosnia and Bulgaria, who come into the country seeking jobs and benefits. Because of the media's representation of these types of people, as confirmed during the recent Leveson Inquiry, has lead people to conform to this stereotype of foreign people as people who all work for minimum wage. In addition, sound and mise en scene are also used to demonstrate a different stereotype of European ethnicity, specifically Italians. Within the diegetic sound bridge of dialogue exchanged between the Italian and the British chef in the kitchen, the Italian chef calls the other a "British Plague". This is the same word David Cameron used to describe the mass migration of people fleeing from their countries into Britain which the media took advantage off making multiple headline news stories about it. Since, it has been a word associated with immigrants coming into Britain. This therefore is ironic to have the Italian chef, who migrated to Britain for work to call the British Chef "British Plague". Proceeding this, he begins to pick up a knife ready to have a fight. This in conjunction with his comment conform to the stereotype of Italian people being hot-blooded and ready to have a fight at any given time, further showing how ethnicity is represented within this media text.
Furthermore, camera, mise en scene and sound are used to represent race during the conversation between two black characters. The diegetic dialogue exchanged between the characters, shown during a shot reverse shot including words such as "Booze", "Girls", "Blud" and "Ganja" conforms to Alvarado's Race Theory of black people stereotypically being depicted as sexual, thug-like and and criminal people. The way in which the characters are standing also confirm this. One of the characters stands with a square-on, aggressive stance, typical of a person who would be ready to fight for example. This conforms to the thug-like stereotype outlined by Alvarado but also relates to Cohen who said that people have become fearful of certain races due to world events that have occurred, and due to "the black mugger", gangsterism and riots have stereotypically included predominantly black people, the media's representation of black people in this way intends to play on common already existing stereotypes. However, there have also been counter stereotypes demonstrated as well. The diegetic dialogue spoken between the two is very different. Whilst one uses vocabulary including words such as "Ganja" the other speaks eloquently. This subverts from the gangster stereotype of Alvarado showing how not all black people fit into this stereotype. This however can also be disproven due to the fact that they both speak with a south-London accent, a region stereotypically associated with black people due to the low income bracket of the area. Additionally, the use of tattoos on one of the characters as opposed to the lack thereof on the other subverts from Alvarado's stereotype of black people being dangerous people due to the connotations of a tattoo alluding to gangs, violence and rebellion.
In continuance, mise en scene and editing are used to represent race during the swimming pool scene. The scene uses the pillars within the swimming pool area to transition between cuts, from a long shot to a panning medium shot back to a long shot. Within each scene, white people are seen drinking champagne, dressed in nice clothes, relaxing whilst the black serviceman on hand is waiting on them. They are shown wearing white or gold clothing. These colours have connotations of purity, wealth and status. This is a subtle reference to white privilege being that they are the only, apart from one person, race present in such a hotel. This alludes to the fact that the white race has been perceived as being the superior race and depicts how race is something that equates to status.
Moreover, editing and mise en scene are also used to depict ethnicity during the scene where two people are seen walking down the kitchen corridor. There are quick transitions between the scenes showing a medium two shot, alternative perspective close up shots and tracking full two shots. During these shots, people are walking past the two people wearing head caps. This is typically associated with people in the Islamic faith which they wear as a symbol of respect to their God. An element of tokenism could be argued here due to the fact that those people didn't need to be, as inferred by the cap, Islamic people, it could've been any worker, however they are used instead, which one could argue is due to the fact that Hotel Babylon is criticising or conforming to the stereotype of people from foreign countries being people who come to the country to work on minimum wage.
In conclusion, representation of ethnicity and race are broadly shown within the clip. However, David Gauntlet pointed out that the level of representation of different ethnicities and races by the media needs to be contained which is a theory that can be applied in this clip due to the representation of ethnicities and races are being done through ethnocentricism, a theory developed by Elizabeth Poole whereby a representation is made through one's own culture.
Firstly, camera, sound and mise en scene are used to represent ethnicity when there is a panning shot on the maids. They are shown wheeling carts and wearing maids outfits; the standard black dress with the white apron and a white hair tie. When they spoke, they spoke with a Franco-British accent, evident that they had been living in the country for some time after having migrated here. This conforms to the typical stereotype of eastern European people coming into the country and taking all of the blue collar public sector jobs that are in the UK. This has recently been made a common stereotype through people from countries all over Europe, such as Bosnia and Bulgaria, who come into the country seeking jobs and benefits. Because of the media's representation of these types of people, as confirmed during the recent Leveson Inquiry, has lead people to conform to this stereotype of foreign people as people who all work for minimum wage. In addition, sound and mise en scene are also used to demonstrate a different stereotype of European ethnicity, specifically Italians. Within the diegetic sound bridge of dialogue exchanged between the Italian and the British chef in the kitchen, the Italian chef calls the other a "British Plague". This is the same word David Cameron used to describe the mass migration of people fleeing from their countries into Britain which the media took advantage off making multiple headline news stories about it. Since, it has been a word associated with immigrants coming into Britain. This therefore is ironic to have the Italian chef, who migrated to Britain for work to call the British Chef "British Plague". Proceeding this, he begins to pick up a knife ready to have a fight. This in conjunction with his comment conform to the stereotype of Italian people being hot-blooded and ready to have a fight at any given time, further showing how ethnicity is represented within this media text.
Furthermore, camera, mise en scene and sound are used to represent race during the conversation between two black characters. The diegetic dialogue exchanged between the characters, shown during a shot reverse shot including words such as "Booze", "Girls", "Blud" and "Ganja" conforms to Alvarado's Race Theory of black people stereotypically being depicted as sexual, thug-like and and criminal people. The way in which the characters are standing also confirm this. One of the characters stands with a square-on, aggressive stance, typical of a person who would be ready to fight for example. This conforms to the thug-like stereotype outlined by Alvarado but also relates to Cohen who said that people have become fearful of certain races due to world events that have occurred, and due to "the black mugger", gangsterism and riots have stereotypically included predominantly black people, the media's representation of black people in this way intends to play on common already existing stereotypes. However, there have also been counter stereotypes demonstrated as well. The diegetic dialogue spoken between the two is very different. Whilst one uses vocabulary including words such as "Ganja" the other speaks eloquently. This subverts from the gangster stereotype of Alvarado showing how not all black people fit into this stereotype. This however can also be disproven due to the fact that they both speak with a south-London accent, a region stereotypically associated with black people due to the low income bracket of the area. Additionally, the use of tattoos on one of the characters as opposed to the lack thereof on the other subverts from Alvarado's stereotype of black people being dangerous people due to the connotations of a tattoo alluding to gangs, violence and rebellion.
In continuance, mise en scene and editing are used to represent race during the swimming pool scene. The scene uses the pillars within the swimming pool area to transition between cuts, from a long shot to a panning medium shot back to a long shot. Within each scene, white people are seen drinking champagne, dressed in nice clothes, relaxing whilst the black serviceman on hand is waiting on them. They are shown wearing white or gold clothing. These colours have connotations of purity, wealth and status. This is a subtle reference to white privilege being that they are the only, apart from one person, race present in such a hotel. This alludes to the fact that the white race has been perceived as being the superior race and depicts how race is something that equates to status.
Moreover, editing and mise en scene are also used to depict ethnicity during the scene where two people are seen walking down the kitchen corridor. There are quick transitions between the scenes showing a medium two shot, alternative perspective close up shots and tracking full two shots. During these shots, people are walking past the two people wearing head caps. This is typically associated with people in the Islamic faith which they wear as a symbol of respect to their God. An element of tokenism could be argued here due to the fact that those people didn't need to be, as inferred by the cap, Islamic people, it could've been any worker, however they are used instead, which one could argue is due to the fact that Hotel Babylon is criticising or conforming to the stereotype of people from foreign countries being people who come to the country to work on minimum wage.
In conclusion, representation of ethnicity and race are broadly shown within the clip. However, David Gauntlet pointed out that the level of representation of different ethnicities and races by the media needs to be contained which is a theory that can be applied in this clip due to the representation of ethnicities and races are being done through ethnocentricism, a theory developed by Elizabeth Poole whereby a representation is made through one's own culture.


























